Place a Shipping Order
Place a Pick Up Order
Lisa's Pie Shop
5995 S US Highway 31
Atlanta, IN 46031
Phone: 317.758.6944
Note: Tax will be calculated at end of check out. For large orders with multiple recipients or to set up a corporate account, please send an email request to We will work with you to gather the details of your order and to provide you with a time/cost estimate.
Welcome to the Pie in a Jar Gift Shop

We offer the finest homemade pies and are recognized as the top independent baker in the country. However, there is one surprise we offer pies in a jar. That’s right crust and all comes directly to you in a jar.


Standard Menu - Apple, Apricot, Peach, Blueberry, Cherry, Strawberry Rhubarb
Standard Menu $4.00
Black Raspberry $5.00
Standard Menu $6.00
Black Raspberry $7.00
Standard Menu $10.00
Black Raspberry $12.00
*** Shipping 1-6 jars $13.90; 6-12 jars $27.80
Created by